Performance Goals vs. Cosmetic Goals

by Tyler Hass

 

 

We are now one month into the new year and according to statistics, most New Year's resolutions have already bitten the dust. One study showed that 60% of people failed to succeed with whatever goal they set on December 31st. One problem I see with most goals is that people set output-oriented goals, or cosmetic goals, instead of input-oriented or performance goals. Rather than saying that you would like to run a 200m in 24 seconds and perform 15 pullups, most people set a goal such as losing 10 pounds and adding an inch to their biceps. This goal is pretty ambiguous, because it does not say how the goal will be reached and does not focus on the process. The second problem people run into is that even if they do lose the weight, they tend not to look or feel any better. After crash dieting and some aerobics, people lose some fat, but some muscle as well. The end result is little change in body composition, the ratio of lean body mass to fat. Furthermore, as soon as these people go back to their normal habits, their weight will come back with a vengeance. Not being any stronger or fitter than they were the first time, they are back to square one and it will be just as hard to lose the weight as it was the first time. If you have a relapse, but you have improve your strength and work capacity, you will be able to improve your appearance much more quickly.

Many people, when they begin a good training program get great results without even trying. One day they just realize they are getting strong and lean. I have heard a lot of stories like this from Kettlebell lifters. Usually within the first months of training, they increase their workload by about 50%, sometimes even double. This training process, which led to an increase in performance, also resulted in an improved physique. Even better results will come when the lifter becomes even more advanced. The ability to handle more difficult loads will manifest itself in an improved appearance. Form follows function!

One important note must be made, however. You must be careful what type of performance increase you pursue. If you pursue an increase in aerobic endurance, you will likely burn as much muscle as fat. If you seek pure muscular strength, you will gain improved muscle tone, but you will not likely burn any fat or lose weight, because strength is a neuromuscular skill. It is very difficult to distinguish two people based on neuromuscular properties alone. Can you tell the difference between a person who can juggle and one who cannot? That might be a bit extreme, but my point is that improved neural abilities alone are unlikely to change your appearance. At the same time though, they can be extremely valuable in achieving other goals. For example, if you improve your squatting and/or deadlifting strength, you will become a better kettlebell lifter as a byproduct of that training. Improved strength will allow you to handle a tougher workload, which is very beneficial for pursuing a cosmetic goal. Weak stimuli produce muted results. Pumping a color-coded dumbbell will not get you anywhere, despite what the "pump and shape" crowd tells you. Strong stimuli will lead to dramatic results. For example, Arnold Schwarznegger was a powerlifter before he became a bodybuilder. As a result, he was able to train with heavy weights, giving him more benefit out of each rep. If Joe Average were to starting following Arnold's routine, there is no way he would get the same results. Squatting 180 for three sets of 10 reps will not do too much for muscle building. Three sets of 10 with 300+ pounds will do much more if hypertrophy is your goal. Before deciding to bulk up, establish a base of strength by training like a powerlifter. This is the problem I see most guys running into. They want to get huge NOW and every magazine is telling them it will only take 4-6 weeks. One month of pumping puny weights for high reps is not going to add much bulk, nor will the strength increase be that great.

When people look at the physiques of great athletes, they see something unattainable. They attribute it to genetics or drugs. These same people don't even think twice about picking up a bodybuilding magazine and trying the latest arm routine and buying the latest supplement! If you want to talk unattainable, let's use the bodybuilders in the magazines as the perfect example. Their physiques are temporary results of crash diets, diuretics, good lighting, make-up and computer retouching. Contrast that with athletes- what you see is what you get. They do not even try to look good. Their physiques are an unintended result of pursuing higher and higher levels of performance. I've seen some top athletes train and I was pretty shocked that they were doing a combination of aerobics and piecemeal bodybuilding routines. Nationally ranked college tennis players were performing curls, leg extensions and jogging for miles. Even with poor training programs, they looked pretty good. Their high fitness levels were mostly a result of tough practices on the court. This should give hope to the rest of us, because we have access to the best training programs in the world. It is not easy, but we can achieve the fitness levels of top athletes. This will not give us their skills, which is what makes them great, but at least we can look just as good.

To set your goals, take a look at top athletes and pick what you want. Gymnasts have incredible upper body and torso strength, amazing flexibility and body control. Olympic weightlifters have incredible strength and power in the hips, legs and back, plus they rank high in the flexibility category. These athletes have certain traits like balance and technique that will be difficult to develop, but these are neuromuscular skills, so you don't need them just to look good. Of course, you can have some fun and a healthy challenge in trying to develop these skills. Sprinters have incredible explosiveness and speed. Contrast the lean, muscular physique of the sprinter to the emaciated physique of the marathon runner and you will wonder why people spend so much time running for hours on treadmills. Basketball players are known for their powerful leaping abilities, agility and speed. They are also among the leanest of all professional athletes, averaging around 5% bodyfat. Looking at the event itself, it is a game with a lot of rest periods spread throughout, punctuated by many brief bursts of power and explosiveness. This work to rest ratio proves that you do not need continuous exertions to burn fat. Kettlebell lifters are known for their incredible work capacities and balance between strength and endurance. This type of training leaves almost no physical attribute untouched- strength, power, speed, endurance, balance, etc. In Vorpayev's study of Kettlebell training versus standard calisthenics training, the Kettlebell lifting group outperformed the other group in each of a wide variety of tests. This is despite the fact that they did nothing to specifically prepare for the tests and the other group trained in the same events as they were tested in. This should be a powerful testament to the performance enhancing effects of kettlebell training. Old-time strongmen are famous for their incredible feats of strength, as well as their amazing physiques. Many of them were accomplished wrestlers, gymnasts and athletes as well.

What can we take away from this survey of the athletic spectrum? This diverse group trains in a wide variety of ways, but each is rewarded with a good physique. They come from mostly anaerobic sports, which are explosive but short in duration. Thus, when training for a better physique, go hard and fast. Brief, intense workouts can work miracles. There is no need to become a master at any of these disciplines, because the basics work all of the same muscle groups. Aim for improvement and proficiency, but remember that it takes quality coaching and an incredible investment of time and effort to develop the skills of these athletes. You will derive great benefit from the training long before you achieve mastery in the discipline. Drawing from a basic collection of exercises that tax all of the major muscle groups, you can design a very effective training program. Below I list a sampling of exercises from a variety of sports. The CrossFit program, which incorporates many of these movements, has a huge variety of templates that you can use or you can even follow their workout of the day. You can also easily design your own training program, picking elements you like from any of these sports.
Gymnastics- pull-ups, dips, L-sits, ice cream makers, handstand pushups, press into handstands, walking on hands, tumbling
Olympic Weightlifting- Snatch, Clean and Jerk, variations of both exercises
Sprinting- Sprints in a variety of distances: 50m, 100m, 200m, 400m, etc.
Kettlebell lifting- any type of Kettlebell training that will lead to improvement in competitive Girevoy sport
Old-time strongmen- incorporate a wide variety of training, but focus mainly on events that challenge the whole body, like bent presses.
Kickboxing- heavy bag work and Thai pads if you have a partner. Focus on good footwork and fight an imaginary opponent who is trying to hit you.